External hard drive finder: which SSD or hard drive should you buy?
Answer 5 short questions and see the 5 external drives that suit you best.
40 drives compared from the makers' spec sheets and expert reviews. How we rank
The questions
40 drives compared from the makers' spec sheets and expert reviews. How we rank
Picks for common needs
Choose a need to see its top 5. You can change any answer after.
For backing up a computer
- Number 1: Seagate Expansion Desktop 16 TBAbout $450
- Number 2: WD My Passport 6 TBAbout $270
- Number 3: Seagate One Touch HDD 4 TBAbout $200
For a Mac
- Number 1: Lexar ES5 Magnetic Portable SSD 2 TBAbout $410
- Number 2: Samsung T7 Shield 2 TBAbout $520
- Number 3: SanDisk Creator Phone SSD 2 TBAbout $350
For a phone or iPad
- Number 1: Lexar ES5 Magnetic Portable SSD 2 TBAbout $410
- Number 2: SanDisk Creator Phone SSD 2 TBAbout $350
- Number 3: SanDisk Extreme Portable SSD 2 TBAbout $460
For a PS5
- Number 1: SanDisk Optimus GX PRO 850X (WD_BLACK SN850X) with Heatsink 2 TBAbout $510
- Number 2: Samsung 990 PRO with Heatsink 2 TBAbout $670
- Number 3: SanDisk Optimus GX PRO 850X (WD_BLACK SN850X) with Heatsink 1 TBAbout $280
For an Xbox Series X or S
- Number 1: Seagate Storage Expansion Card for Xbox Series X|S 2 TBAbout $350
- Number 2: SanDisk Optimus GX C50 (WD_BLACK C50) Xbox Expansion Card 2 TBAbout $480
- Number 3: Lexar ES5 Magnetic Portable SSD 2 TBAbout $410
Answer the questions
Up to 5 short questions. Your own top 5 at the end.
All 40 drives, ranked
Ranked by expert reviews and value for money, before any answers. How we rank
Prices checked .
Number 1: Lexar ES5 Magnetic Portable SSD 2 TB
About $410
Portable SSD2 TB
Details: Lexar ES5 Magnetic Portable SSD 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Very fast
- Toughness
- Water-resistant
- Most expert reviews rate it very highly
- It gets hot during long recordings, reviewers measured
Number 2: Samsung T7 Shield 2 TB
About $520
Portable SSD2 TB
Details: Samsung T7 Shield 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Fast
- Toughness
- Water-resistant
- Most expert reviews rate it very highly
- Half the speed of newer drives that cost about the same
Number 3: Seagate One Touch HDD 4 TB
About $200
Portable hard drive4 TB
Details: Seagate One Touch HDD 4 TB
- Holds
- 4 TB
- Type
- Portable hard drive
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- No rating
- Lots of space for the money: about $50 per terabyte
- Its USB-C cable is short, and older USB-A computers need an adapter
Number 4: WD Elements Portable 6 TB
About $270
Portable hard drive6 TB
Details: WD Elements Portable 6 TB
- Holds
- 6 TB
- Type
- Portable hard drive
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- No rating
- Lots of space for the money: about $45 per terabyte
- No backup software, and only a 2-year warranty
Number 5: WD My Passport 6 TB
About $270
Portable hard drive6 TB
Details: WD My Passport 6 TB
- Holds
- 6 TB
- Type
- Portable hard drive
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- No rating
- Lots of space for the money: about $45 per terabyte
- Comes with a USB-A cable: a MacBook needs an adapter. Format it again to use it on a Mac
Number 6: SanDisk Creator Phone SSD 2 TB
About $350
Portable SSD2 TB
Details: SanDisk Creator Phone SSD 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Fast
- Toughness
- Water-resistant
- Water and dust resistant, and survives drops of up to 10 ft
- Half the speed of the Lexar ES5, and its cable is long for a phone
Number 7: SanDisk Extreme Portable SSD 2 TB
About $460
Portable SSD2 TB
Details: SanDisk Extreme Portable SSD 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Fast
- Toughness
- Water-resistant
- Water and dust resistant, and survives drops of up to 10 ft
- SanDisk is replacing it with a newer version, so stock may run out
Number 8: Samsung T9 2 TB
About $470
Portable SSD2 TB
Details: Samsung T9 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Very fast
- Toughness
- Drop-tested
- You can lock it with a password
- Its top speed needs a 20 Gbps USB port, which few laptops have. Most run it at half speed
Number 9: Seagate Portable 5 TB
About $210
Portable hard drive5 TB
Details: Seagate Portable 5 TB
- Holds
- 5 TB
- Type
- Portable hard drive
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- No rating
- Lots of space for the money: about $40 per terabyte
- Only a 1-year warranty, and no backup software
Number 10: Samsung Portable SSD P9 2 TB
About $650
Portable SSD2 TB
Details: Samsung Portable SSD P9 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Fastest
- Toughness
- Drop-tested
- One of the fastest drives you can buy
- After about 150 GB in one go, writing slows down a lot, reviewers measured
Number 11: Samsung BAR Plus 256 GB
About $80
USB stick256 GB
Details: Samsung BAR Plus 256 GB
- Holds
- 256 GB
- Type
- USB stick
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- No rating
- Reviewers rate it well for what it costs
- Writes slowly: filling it takes over an hour, reviewers measured. USB-A plug only
Number 12: LaCie Rugged SSD4 2 TB
About $780
Portable SSD2 TB
Details: LaCie Rugged SSD4 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Fastest
- Toughness
- Splash-proof
- Splash-proof, and survives drops of up to 10 ft
- Hard to find in stock, and it costs far more than at launch
Show all 40 drives
Number 13: Seagate Expansion Desktop 16 TB
About $450
Desktop hard drive16 TB
Details: Seagate Expansion Desktop 16 TB
- Holds
- 16 TB
- Type
- Desktop hard drive
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- No rating
- Lots of space for the money: about $30 per terabyte
- Only a 1-year warranty
Number 14: Kingston XS1000 2 TB
About $360
Portable SSD2 TB
Details: Kingston XS1000 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Fast
- Toughness
- No rating
- Reviewers rate it well for what it costs
- Only a USB-A cable with a small USB-C adapter, and no water rating
Number 15: Lexar ES5 Magnetic Portable SSD 1 TB
About $200
Portable SSD1 TB
Details: Lexar ES5 Magnetic Portable SSD 1 TB
- Holds
- 1 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Very fast
- Toughness
- Water-resistant
- Most expert reviews rate it very highly
- It gets hot during long recordings, reviewers measured
Number 16: Samsung T7 Shield 1 TB
About $290
Portable SSD1 TB
Details: Samsung T7 Shield 1 TB
- Holds
- 1 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Fast
- Toughness
- Water-resistant
- Most expert reviews rate it very highly
- Half the speed of newer drives that cost about the same
Number 17: WD Elements Portable 2 TB
About $130
Portable hard drive2 TB
Details: WD Elements Portable 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Portable hard drive
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- No rating
- Lots of space for the money: about $65 per terabyte
- No backup software, and only a 2-year warranty
Number 18: WD My Passport 2 TB
About $150
Portable hard drive2 TB
Details: WD My Passport 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Portable hard drive
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- No rating
- Lots of space for the money: about $75 per terabyte
- Comes with a USB-A cable: a MacBook needs an adapter. Format it again to use it on a Mac
Number 19: Seagate Game Drive for PS5 5 TB
About $210
Portable hard drive5 TB
Details: Seagate Game Drive for PS5 5 TB
- Holds
- 5 TB
- Type
- Portable hard drive
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- No rating
- Lots of space for the money: about $40 per terabyte
- You pay for the PlayStation look: a plain hard drive does the same job
Number 20: Seagate One Touch HDD 2 TB
About $160
Portable hard drive2 TB
Details: Seagate One Touch HDD 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Portable hard drive
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- No rating
- Lots of space for the money: about $80 per terabyte
- Its USB-C cable is short, and older USB-A computers need an adapter
Number 21: SanDisk Extreme Portable SSD 1 TB
About $220
Portable SSD1 TB
Details: SanDisk Extreme Portable SSD 1 TB
- Holds
- 1 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Fast
- Toughness
- Water-resistant
- Water and dust resistant, and survives drops of up to 10 ft
- SanDisk is replacing it with a newer version, so stock may run out
Number 22: SanDisk Creator Phone SSD 1 TB
About $230
Portable SSD1 TB
Details: SanDisk Creator Phone SSD 1 TB
- Holds
- 1 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Fast
- Toughness
- Water-resistant
- Water and dust resistant, and survives drops of up to 10 ft
- Half the speed of the Lexar ES5, and its cable is long for a phone
Number 23: SanDisk Extreme PRO Dual Drive 1 TB
About $270
USB stick1 TB
Details: SanDisk Extreme PRO Dual Drive 1 TB
- Holds
- 1 TB
- Type
- USB stick
- Speed
- Fast
- Toughness
- No rating
- Comes with backup software
- Full speed needs a 10 Gbps USB port. One plug is always uncovered
Number 24: Samsung T9 1 TB
About $290
Portable SSD1 TB
Details: Samsung T9 1 TB
- Holds
- 1 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Very fast
- Toughness
- Drop-tested
- You can lock it with a password
- Its top speed needs a 20 Gbps USB port, which few laptops have. Most run it at half speed
Number 25: Samsung T9 4 TB
About $1,000
Portable SSD4 TB
Details: Samsung T9 4 TB
- Holds
- 4 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Very fast
- Toughness
- Drop-tested
- You can lock it with a password
- Its top speed needs a 20 Gbps USB port, which few laptops have. Most run it at half speed
Number 26: Seagate Portable 2 TB
About $130
Portable hard drive2 TB
Details: Seagate Portable 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Portable hard drive
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- No rating
- Lots of space for the money: about $65 per terabyte
- Only a 1-year warranty, and no backup software
Number 27: LaCie Rugged Mini 2 TB
About $150
Portable hard drive2 TB
Details: LaCie Rugged Mini 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Portable hard drive
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- Drop-tested
- Lots of space for the money: about $75 per terabyte
- Bulky, and only as fast as any hard drive. Rain-resistant, not waterproof
Number 28: LaCie Rugged SSD4 4 TB
About $1,150
Portable SSD4 TB
Details: LaCie Rugged SSD4 4 TB
- Holds
- 4 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Fastest
- Toughness
- Splash-proof
- Splash-proof, and survives drops of up to 10 ft
- Hard to find in stock, and it costs far more than at launch
Number 29: Seagate Expansion Desktop 8 TB
About $280
Desktop hard drive8 TB
Details: Seagate Expansion Desktop 8 TB
- Holds
- 8 TB
- Type
- Desktop hard drive
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- No rating
- Lots of space for the money: about $35 per terabyte
- Only a 1-year warranty
Number 30: Kingston XS1000 1 TB
About $240
Portable SSD1 TB
Details: Kingston XS1000 1 TB
- Holds
- 1 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Fast
- Toughness
- No rating
- Reviewers rate it well for what it costs
- Only a USB-A cable with a small USB-C adapter, and no water rating
Number 31: LaCie Rugged SSD Pro5 4 TB
About $1,900
Portable SSD4 TB
Details: LaCie Rugged SSD Pro5 4 TB
- Holds
- 4 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Fastest
- Toughness
- Water-resistant
- Water and dust resistant, and survives drops of up to 10 ft
- Very expensive. It is only faster than cheaper fast drives on a new Thunderbolt 5 computer
Number 32: Seagate Expansion Desktop 24 TB
About $700
Desktop hard drive24 TB
Details: Seagate Expansion Desktop 24 TB
- Holds
- 24 TB
- Type
- Desktop hard drive
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- No rating
- Lots of space for the money: about $30 per terabyte
- Only a 1-year warranty
Number 33: Samsung T5 EVO 4 TB
About $580
Portable SSD4 TB
Details: Samsung T5 EVO 4 TB
- Holds
- 4 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- Drop-tested
- You can lock it with a password
- Expert reviews are mixed
Number 34: SanDisk Optimus GX PRO 850X (WD_BLACK SN850X) with Heatsink 2 TB
About $510
SSD for inside a PS52 TB
Details: SanDisk Optimus GX PRO 850X (WD_BLACK SN850X) with Heatsink 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- SSD for inside a PS5
- Speed
- As fast as the console's own storage
- Toughness
- Stays in the console
- Most expert reviews rate it very highly
- Older boxes say WD_BLACK SN850X: it is the same drive
Number 35: Samsung T5 EVO 8 TB
About $1,300
Portable SSD8 TB
Details: Samsung T5 EVO 8 TB
- Holds
- 8 TB
- Type
- Portable SSD
- Speed
- Like a hard drive
- Toughness
- Drop-tested
- You can lock it with a password
- Expert reviews are mixed
Number 36: Samsung 990 PRO with Heatsink 2 TB
About $670
SSD for inside a PS52 TB
Details: Samsung 990 PRO with Heatsink 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- SSD for inside a PS5
- Speed
- As fast as the console's own storage
- Toughness
- Stays in the console
- Most expert reviews rate it very highly
- Costs more than other drives that play PS5 games just as well
Number 37: Seagate Storage Expansion Card for Xbox Series X|S 2 TB
About $350
Xbox expansion card2 TB
Details: Seagate Storage Expansion Card for Xbox Series X|S 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Xbox expansion card
- Speed
- As fast as the console's own storage
- Toughness
- Stays in the console
- Plays Xbox Series X and S games straight from the card
- Costs much more per terabyte than a USB drive, which can still store Xbox games
Number 38: SanDisk Optimus GX C50 (WD_BLACK C50) Xbox Expansion Card 2 TB
About $480
Xbox expansion card2 TB
Details: SanDisk Optimus GX C50 (WD_BLACK C50) Xbox Expansion Card 2 TB
- Holds
- 2 TB
- Type
- Xbox expansion card
- Speed
- As fast as the console's own storage
- Toughness
- Stays in the console
- Plays Xbox Series X and S games straight from the card
- Costs more than the Seagate card that does the same job. Older boxes say WD_BLACK C50
Number 39: SanDisk Optimus GX PRO 850X (WD_BLACK SN850X) with Heatsink 1 TB
About $280
SSD for inside a PS51 TB
Details: SanDisk Optimus GX PRO 850X (WD_BLACK SN850X) with Heatsink 1 TB
- Holds
- 1 TB
- Type
- SSD for inside a PS5
- Speed
- As fast as the console's own storage
- Toughness
- Stays in the console
- Most expert reviews rate it very highly
- Older boxes say WD_BLACK SN850X: it is the same drive
Number 40: SanDisk Optimus GX PRO 850X (WD_BLACK SN850X) with Heatsink 4 TB
About $980
SSD for inside a PS54 TB
Details: SanDisk Optimus GX PRO 850X (WD_BLACK SN850X) with Heatsink 4 TB
- Holds
- 4 TB
- Type
- SSD for inside a PS5
- Speed
- As fast as the console's own storage
- Toughness
- Stays in the console
- Most expert reviews rate it very highly
- Older boxes say WD_BLACK SN850X: it is the same drive
What matters when you choose an external drive
Only a few things really change which drive suits you.
- What it is for. A backup needs lots of space for the money, so a hard drive is often the smart choice. A drive you carry needs to be small and tough. Video work needs a fast SSD.
- What you plug it into. Every USB drive here works with Windows and Mac. A phone needs an SSD or a USB-C stick. A PS5 or an Xbox has its own rules for new games, and we follow them.
- How much it holds. Price grows with size, and drive prices rose a lot in 2026. Above 4 TB, a hard drive costs a fraction of an SSD.
- Where it lives. Hard drives have spinning parts and don’t like knocks. For a bag or outdoors, choose an SSD with a water and drop rating.
Some things matter less than the box suggests:
- The top speed on the box. It is measured in the best case, and your port often limits it. A Mac runs the 20 Gbps drives at half speed. We use the speed reviewers measured.
- Very fast drives for photos and documents. Any SSD here feels quick for those. Very fast drives pay off for big video files, and only on a fast port.
- “Gaming” drives. For games on a PC, any good SSD works. For consoles, only the rules above matter.
How we ranked them
We read the maker’s spec sheet for every drive, and at least one expert review. Most come from StorageReview, Tom’s Hardware, PCWorld and TechRadar. Every drive on the list is sold in the US now, and we checked prices in November 2026. Each size of a drive is its own entry, because each size has its own price.
Before you answer, the list is sorted by how highly the reviews rate each drive, how much it costs, and how much space you get for the money. Your answers then add weight to what you need. Choose a backup, and space for the money counts most. Choose video, and the speed reviewers measured counts most. Choose outdoors, and water and drop ratings count most.
Some answers rule drives out. A phone never gets a hard drive. A drive that needs a wall socket never shows for a bag. A console only gets drives that work in it. If you ask for a size or a budget, we show those first. If fewer than 5 fit, we show the closest ones and say what they miss.
Each pick says why it fits you and what to keep in mind. We never call a drive “the best” for everyone. Nobody paid to be on this list.
Questions and answers
Should I get an SSD or a hard drive?
For backups that stay on a desk, a hard drive gives you far more space for the money. For a drive you carry, or for video and games, get an SSD. It has no moving parts, so a knock or a drop won't hurt it, and it copies files about 5 to 10 times faster.
Hard drives need careful handling: don't move one while it is running.
How much storage do I need?
For a backup, pick about twice the storage of your computer. A laptop with 512 GB needs a 1 TB drive, so there is room for older copies of your files.
1 TB holds about 200,000 phone photos, or about 40 hours of 4K phone video. For editing video, 2 TB is a sensible start.
Which external drive works with a PS5?
Any USB SSD or hard drive from 250 GB to 8 TB works. PS4 games play from it, but PS5 games only wait there: you move them back to play. To play PS5 games from extra storage, fit an M.2 SSD with a heatsink inside the console. It takes a small screwdriver and about 15 minutes. Choose A PlayStation 5 and the finder shows both.
Can I play Xbox Series X games from an external drive?
Only from an Xbox expansion card, which plugs into the slot on the back. A normal USB drive plays older Xbox One games, and it stores Series X and S games, but you move them back to play. Choose An Xbox Series X or S and the expansion cards come first.
Does an external drive work with an iPhone?
Yes, if the iPhone has a USB-C plug (iPhone 15 or newer). An SSD or a USB-C stick works; a hard drive may need more power than the phone gives. Your photos and videos show up in the Files app. iPhone Pro models can also film straight onto a fast SSD.
Not affiliated with or endorsed by any maker or shop. Product photos are the makers' own. To have one removed, email hello@devicetests.com.

























